[Mova](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/) · [this page in HTML](https://mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/papers/henschel-1994-merged-upper-model-linguistic-ontology/) [home](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/) / [docs](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/) / [papers](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/papers/) / [English](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/papers/en/) / The Merged Upper Model: A Linguistic Ontology for German and English # The Merged Upper Model: A Linguistic Ontology for German and English **Authors:** Renate Henschel, John Bateman · **Year:** 1994 · **Venue:** COLING 1994, Volume 2: The 15th International Conference on Computational Linguistics **Link:** [aclanthology.org/C94-2128](https://aclanthology.org/C94-2128/) · **Licence:** [CC BY-NC-SA 3.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/) (ACL Anthology, before 2016) — summary only; the text is partly garbled by OCR, so this card rests on the readable parts [**1** citations in our library](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/papers/cited-by/henschel-1994-merged-upper-model-linguistic-ontology/) of the 140673 papers whose bibliographies we read[COLING 1994 Volume 2: The 15th International Conference on Computational Linguistics](https://aclanthology.org/volumes/C94-2/)[licence](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/) - [Publisher's page](https://aclanthology.org/C94-2128/) - [PDF](https://aclanthology.org/C94-2128.pdf) **Authors (2)** 1. Renate Henschel [Semantic Scholar](https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/28774373) 2. John Bateman [Semantic Scholar](https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/1736968) Citations and author metrics from OpenAlex (); authors with the same name are not always told apart. ## What it is about The paper merges two linguistically motivated upper models used for sentence generation: the English Upper Model (about 252 concepts after removing rhetorical relations) and the German Upper Model (about 235 concepts). The method follows Hovy and Nirenburg: each pair of concepts is classed as identity, extension or cross-classification. Three principles guide the merge. First, remove distinctions that are not experiential (for example clause versus prepositional phrase), since they only record how a meaning is worded. Second, replace exhaustive cross-classification with an "intelligent" one, dropping cross-classes whose role sets contradict each other (the material-process hierarchy is the worked example: directed actions with a causer, nondirected actions with or without one). Third, let the semantics-grammar interface allow roles to be left unrealised, so a single process concept serves for passives and optional participants. The merged model has 288 concepts. Strong identity covers 41% of the merged concepts, identity after unifying concepts 63%, extension about 25%, cross-classification 3.6%. The merged model is used for sentence generation in English, German and Dutch. ## Ideas - I1. An English verb-class table in `world`: nondirected-doing (agent only: *run*), nondirected-happening (affected only: *wilt*), directed-action (causer plus affected: *break*). Each lexical verb is assigned one class, and the class fixes which role a single argument takes ("The vase broke" against "The child broke the vase"). - I2. An intelligent merge rule for overlapping lexical classes: when a verb belongs to two classes whose role sets contradict each other (one requires an agent, the other forbids one), keep the class that matches the parse and log the discarded class. - I3. A removal rule for non-experiential distinctions: two frame entries that differ only in how the event is worded (clause or nominal) must map to one event concept. Count such duplicates in Mova's frame table, and check that the count goes to zero after the merge. - I4. A negative control for the merge: a shuffled verb-to-class assignment must give more role conflicts with the parse than the true table. ## For Mova The chapters are [13. Verbs](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/languages/en/13-verbs/) (transitivity and the causative pattern of *break*, *open*, *melt*), [21. The simple clause](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/languages/en/21-clause-structure/) (participants and their roles in a clause) and [19. The lexicon: vocabulary, multiword expressions and register](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/languages/en/19-lexicon-mwe-register/) (the lexicon and its word senses). The code is `world/src/events.rs` (event concepts), `prag/src/frames.rs` (role frames) and `en/src/dict.rs` (the verb entries). The measures: the number of role conflicts between a verb's class and its parsed frame on the verb list, before and after the intelligent merge, run twice for identical output, and the shuffled-class negative control. ## Cite The paper itself, not this card. BibTeX from the library's record of the work. ``` @inproceedings{henschel1994merged, title = {{The Merged Upper Model: A Linguistic Ontology for German and English}}, author = {Henschel, Renate and Bateman, John}, booktitle = {COLING 1994 Volume 2: The 15th International Conference on Computational Linguistics}, year = {1994}, url = {https://aclanthology.org/C94-2128/} } ``` - [← previous A history of English](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/papers/hejna-2022-history-english/) - [next → A Compositional Semantics of Temporal Expressions in English](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/papers/hinrichs-1987-compositional-semantics-temporal-expressions-english/) - [↑ back to English](https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/papers/en/) ## References 13 references, 0 of them with a card of ours. ↗ leads to the work, «find» searches for one we have no id for yet. 1. John A. l~ateman, Robert; T. Kasper, Johanna 1). Moore, and Richard A. Whir> hey. A general organization of knowledge Ibr natural language, processing: the PENMAN upper nrodel. Technical report, USC'/Infornmtion Sci ences Institute, Marina del Rey, Calilbrnia, 1990. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=John+A%2E+l%7Eateman%2C+Robert%3B+T%2E+Kasper%2C+Johanna+1%29%2E+Moore%2C+and+Richard+A%2E+Whir%3E+hey%2E+A+general+organization+of+knowledge+Ibr+natural+language%2C+processing%3A+the+PENMAN+upper+nrodel%2E+Technical+report%2C+USC%27%2F) 2. John A. Bateman, Elisa. bel;h A. Mater, FAke 'li'.ich, and Leo Wanner. Towards an architecture for situated text gen era.l;ion. [n [nlernalional Co~@r('ncc on Cur-renl lssucs in Compulalional Linguislics, Penang, Malaysia, 1991. Also available as technical report of GM D/Institut fiir Integricr~e Publikations und Informationssystem G Darmstadt, (~ermauy. [13atelnan el al.,1991b] John A. BaLenlau, Christian M.I.M. Matthiessen> Kelzo Nanri, and Licheng Zeng. 'Pile re-use of linguistic resources a.cross laatgua.g(~s in ttmlt;ilii~gu;d g(2n(~r~l;ion (:()nl port{mrs. In 1}'cocccdi'ngs of the 199l h~ter~.alional ,/oi'nl Co~@:r'c:'tce on Ar't{licial l~tlclligc~cc, ,gyd-n~:y, A'uslralia, VO]lll[l( ~. 2, I)~tg,!s 9(;0 971. Morg~l.it I~a.ut'ula.nn Publish~'rs, 1991. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=John+A%2E+Bateman%2C+Elisa%2E+bel%3Bh+A%2E+Mater%2C+FAke+%27li%27%2Eich%2C+and+Leo+Wanner%2E+Towards+an+architecture+for+situated+text+gen+era%2El%3Bion%2E+%5Bn+%5Bnlernalional+Co%7E%40r%28%27ncc+on+Cur%2Drenl+lssucs+in+Compulalional+Linguisl) 3. John A. I{a,t(~ltl;m. 'l'h(~' th(~orel;ical sl,~t;us of ol,tologi(~s in ira.rural I~mguagc proc('ssing;. In Susanne I}P(m/3 and I~irtc S(;lunit.z, (xlil, ors, 7'e:cl ltep~'csc:'~,lalio~z and I)o~ain Modelli:'lg idca.s ,/7"o~1t liT~gui.slics and !t 1, I);tgcs 50 99. I{l'l'-ILcl}or{. 97, Technisch{~ Univorsitiit I{erlin, M~ty I992. (I}aI){',rs fronl I~I'I'-FAST W{)rlfsll(}t) , 'l'echnicM Uuivcrsigy Iterliu, ()cl;ol){~r 9 t h - 1 l t,h 1991). [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=John+A%2E+I%7Ba%2Ct%28%7Eltl%3Bm%2E+%27l%27h%28%7E%27+th%28%7Eorel%3Bical+sl%2C%7Et%3Bus+of+ol%2Ctologi%28%7Es+in+ira%2Erural+I%7Emguagc+proc%28%27ssing%3B%2E+In+Susanne+I%7DP%28m%2F3+and+I%7Eirtc+S%28%3Blunit%2Ez%2C+%28xlil%2C+ors%2C+7%27e%3Acl+ltep%7E%27csc%3A%27%7E%2Clalio%7Ez+and+I%29o%7Eain+M) 4. Jolm A. P,~teman. Tow~trds Me~ming-Ilascd M~tchinc 'l'r;msl~t.ion: using ~d)-sl,ra.cl, ions rrom text; gencr~ti.ion For i}res(:rving m(~aning. Machinc 'lS'anslaliolG6(I):l 37, 1992. (Slmcia.I {xliti{}n ()It |tie rote or l{~xt; g{:ttoraA, iol~ iu MT). [(luariuo, 1994] Nicola. (;uarino. 'l'h(' o]ll,ological level. In IL. (?asa.{i, II, Smi{,l~, ~m{I (I. Whir, c, {~ditors, l}hilo.soph?] a~*d I1~(' (;og~ilivc ,%'cie:'lccs. Iliilder-I)i{;hlc.r-T('.ml)sky, Vi('.lllla., 1994, [ll~flliday and Matl, hiessetl, |o a.l)l)t~.a.i'] Mich~u!/ A.K. llalliday ~xud (Jhristia.n M.I.M. M~tl;t, hie:;sc'n. (/o'lt.slT'iti*t{t (:a:pcric~zcc lhro:'t(jh :'~c(tni:'z,q: a l¢l~g'ttage-bascd approach 1o cwp~ilio:'L de (Iruyl,er, Berlin, Lo al~pea,'. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Jolm+A%2E+P%2C%7Eteman%2E+Tow%7Etrds+Me%7Eming%2DIlascd+M%7Etchinc+%27l%27r%3Bmsl%7Et%2Eion%3A+using+%7Ed%29%2Dsl%2Cra%2Ecl%2C+ions+rrom+text%3B+gencr%7Eti%2Eion+For+i%7Dres%28%3Arving+m%28%7Eaning%2E+Machinc+%27lS%27anslaliolG6%28I%29%3Al+37%2C+1992%2E+%28Slmcia%2EI+%7Bxliti%7B%7D) 5. ILcn~l,~, I I~m,qcll~q. M~u'ging I:ll~ Iqn-g;lish ;rod i;hc (](~rman IJI)I)(~," Mo(l(~l. q'(~(:llnical r(~ I~O,'1., (;Ml)/lnstitui; fiir lut~grilikal, ions-ultd Ii~f()rHl~tlionssysl.¢?nl( G I)~rul.ql:acll., (*,ernta~y, 1{)93. [[Iol~c<~k, 1!)89] Ih;lnml. lloPac(A¢. 'lbwards lMnci pl(!s oF outology. In 1). Mel.ziD.g, ~'dit,or, Ptocccd-i,gs oJ'thc (;cr,n.a~. Work:.shop or* Arl~[Jicial h~lclli-.(le'~t(:(: (; WA 18,9, p;tgo.q "/23 3;10. SIMngor.¥Mrla.g, Ilerlil,, Ilcidelb~!rg, N(~w York, 1989. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=ILcn%7El%2C%7E%2C+I+I%7Em%2Cqcll%7Eq%2E+M%7Eu%27ging+I%3All%7E+Iqn%2Dg%3Blish+%3Brod+i%3Bhc+%28%5D%28%7Erman+IJI%29I%29%28%7E%2C%22+Mo%28l%28%7El%2E+q%27%28%7E%28%3Allnical+r%28%7E+I%7EO%2C%271%2E%2C+%28%3BMl%29%2Flnstitui%3B+fiir+lut%7Egri%3Cwt%28%7E+Pul%3Elikal%2C+ions%2Dultd+Ii%7Ef%28%29rHl%7Etlionssysl%2E%C2%A2%3Fnl%28+G+) 6. Iqduard Ilovy and Kcviu IKnighl;. Mol, iw~ting sha.rcd kl,owledgc resoul:ce,~< an (~x~mM)l<' fron~ l.h<~ I'~tngloss coltabor~d.ion. In l'rocccdi:'zq,'; o.[' I,](,'AI Work,shop o:'~ l(,o'wl~dyle £ha'~'i'ng a'~d htfo'v~lalion h~lcrch.nge, lnt,crll;t-{.iOI/arl Joint (',Oll['(]l?('.[l('(~ OI1 Arl,ifici~d Intelligence, 1993. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Iqduard+Ilovy+and+Kcviu+IKnighl%3B%2E+Mol%2C+iw%7Eting+sha%2Ercd+kl%2Cowledgc+resoul%3Ace%2C%7E%3C+an+%28%7Ex%7EmM%29l%3C%27+fron%7E+l%2Eh%3C%7E+I%27%7Etngloss+coltabor%7Ed%2Eion%2E+In+l%27rocccdi%3A%27zq%2C%27%3B+o%2E%5B%27+I%2C%5D%28%2C%27AI+Work%2Cshop+o%3A%27%7E+l%28%2Co%27wl%7Edyle+%C2%A3ha%27%7E%27) 7. lq. Ilovy a.nd S. Nit(m-burg. Al~pr()xin~a|il:'g au iul.ccliugua il, a priu-- oil)led way. In t'~'o(ecdin~l,S oJ" /he l),dl~l~/1 ,5'pccch (t:'~,~l Nata~'¢tl l,(t~tguagc Work,shcq~, Ar(Icu Ilot,s~+, New York, 1992. Also av+tilahll> l'rolu [J,q(:/h~forltlation Scionces h,s/.itutc (Marina <1¢;[ H.oy, I,o,~ Angeles) ~t.q 'l'('chnic~d II.~!l)or|. ISI/l:LI/.-93 3d5, I,'l~bua.ry 1!)93. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=lq%2E+Ilovy+a%2End+S%2E+Nit%28m%2Dburg%2E+Al%7Epr%28%29xin%7Ea%7Cil%3A%27g+au+iul%2Eccliugua+il%2C+a+priu%2D%2D+oil%29led+way%2E+In+t%27%7E%27o%28ecdin%7El%2CS+oJ%22+%2Fhe+l%29%2Cdl%7El%7E%2F1+%2C5%27pccch+%28t%3A%27%7E%2C%7El+Nata%7E%27%C2%A2tl+l%2C%28t%7Etguagc+Work%2Cshcq%7E%2C+Ar%28Icu+Ilot%2Cs%7E%2B%2C+Ne) 8. ILol~crt '1'. l(asper. A tlt~xiblc ill l.~;r/'acc For [iuking al)plica|Jons t,o PIqNMAN's .sc:ti-tenet gcuc.r~l.or. In l~rocccdiwIs of lhc I)AIgPA Workshop o:'t ,b'p¢!¢:ch a.d Na, l,ral I,a~guage, 1989, Availabh; from US(~,/lnl'ovmat, ion ,q(:iot/cl~s Insl, i-t;ut(~, M;~ri,ut del ILcy, (IA. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=ILol%7Ecrt+%271%27%2E+l%28asper%2E+A+tlt%7Exiblc+ill+l%2E%7E%3Br%2F%27acc+For+%5Biuking+al%29plica%7CJons+t%2Co+PIqNMAN%27s+%2Esc%3Ati%2Dtenet+gcuc%2Er%7El%2Eor%2E+In+l%7ErocccdiwIs+of+lhc+I%29AIgPA+Workshop+o%3A%27t+%2Cb%27p%C2%A2%21%C2%A2%3Ach+a%2Ed+Na%2C+l%2Cral+I%2Ca%7Eguage%2C+198) 9. Iqwald L~mg. The IAI,OG ontology [rol~l linguistic point of view. In O. Herzog and C.-H,. ILollinger, editors, "l~a:t u~*der,staltding i~t L[I~O(~-inlcgrali~tg co71~putalioTtal linguislics a~td a,'tzJic~al i,.lellige~tcc, l,'inal r'cporl o~ the IBM (;cr~ata~t.y LU,O(~-l}roject, pttges 464 481. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1991. Lecture notes in arti[icDd intelligence, 546. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Iqwald+L%7Emg%2E+The+IAI%2COG+ontology+%5Brol%7El+linguistic+point+of+view%2E+In+O%2E+Herzog+and+C%2E%2DH%2C%2E+ILollinger%2C+editors%2C+%22l%7Ea%3At+u%7E%2Ader%2Cstaltding+i%7Et+L%5BI%7EO%28%7E%2Dinlcgrali%7Etg+co71%7EputalioTtal+linguislics+a%7Etd+a%2C%27tzJ) 10. iLobert M~c(~regor ~nd David I~rill. The LOOM ma,nu~d, 1989, IJS(~/In[ormat, ion ,~cicn(;e!s Institute, Ma,rina, (lel ILey, (~A. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=iLobert+M%7Ec%28%7Eregor+%7End+David+I%7Erill%2E+The+LOOM+ma%2Cnu%7Ed%2C+1989%2C+IJS%28%7E%2FIn%5Bormat%2C+ion+%2C%7Ecicn%28%3Be%21s+Institute%2C+Ma%2Crina%2C+%28lel+ILey%2C+%28%7EA%2E) 11. lL~unesh S. Pautil, l~idlm'd E. I!'ikcs, Petcr I". })atel-Schneidcr, ])ol1 McK~ty, 'l'im Finin, 'l'hGmas II.. (',tuber, ~tnd Robcrt Ncches. The I)AllA'A knowlodge sharing c[[brt: progress report;. [ll ('.haries 1lAth, l{ernhard Nobel, and William IL. Swal'l, olll;, cditors, PT"i~ciples of k~to'lul-edge rep~'esc~llalioTt a~trl ~'ca.so~l.i~tq: p~'occedi~gs of the 1bird in, le,rnalio~lal o~fcre'nce, (',~unbridge, MA, 1!)!)2. Morgan I(~tuI)n~mn. [1%nma,l ProjecL, 1989] P(!lunall lq;ojcc[;. PI,)NMAN docume.utation: l, hc Prime,', the User (~'uid(!, th(~ l~el'cu'cnc(~ M~ml,~d, ~uld the Nigcl nu~nual, 'l'cch nica.l rcporG US(~/InFol:m~tion Scicl,ccs Itlstitul.e, Marin~ dcl l~cy, C~dil'orni~% 1989. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=lL%7Eunesh+S%2E+Pautil%2C+l%7Eidlm%27d+E%2E+I%21%27ikcs%2C+Petcr+I%22%2E+%7D%29atel%2DSchneidcr%2C+%5D%29ol1+McK%7Ety%2C+%27l%27im+Finin%2C+%27l%27hGmas+II%2E%2E+%28%27%2Ctuber%2C+%7Etnd+Robcrt+Ncches%2E+The+I%29AllA%27A+knowlodge+sharing+c%5B%5Bbrt%3A+progress+report%3B%2E+%5Bll) 12. Thomas Pirlcin. ILcusing a. lm'gc dolnain-indcp(!r, dcn/. k.owledge b~sc. In Fifth h~,lcr~zalio~l, al Co~d'cre:'lcc o',. Soflwavc P,'Wli~zcer-i:'U/ a~.d I(~o~t:led:le l(~uli,tteeri~zg (Ht'Jt(l¢'9:']), San l#l:~mcisco, 1993. [find](https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Thomas+Pirlcin%2E+ILcusing+a%2E+lm%27gc+dolnain%2Dindcp%28%21r%2C+dcn%2F%2E+k%2Eowledge+b%7Esc%2E+In+Fifth+h%7E%2Clcr%7Ezalio%7El%2C+al+Co%7Ed%27cre%3A%27lcc+o%27%2C%2E+Soflwavc+P%2C%27Wli%7Ezcer%2Di%3A%27U%2F+a%7E%2Ed+I%28%7Eo%7Et%3Aled%3Ale+l%28%7Euli%2Ctteeri%7Ezg+%28Ht%27Jt%28l%C2%A2%279%3A%27%5D%29%2C) 13. Erich II. Steiuer, [Jrslll& Ib'ck Cwt, Birgit, Weck, ~nd JlltLa. WilH;el'. ']'he dew:l-Ol),neut of the I,'UII.O'I'RA-I) Syf4|,(~,l[| O[' S(~l,l~t,lI;i(' 1'(> la, tions. It, l",rich [l. Sl;ein(,r, P~ml SclHnidt, and C, orneli~ Zelinksy-Wibbclt, editors, l;5"o.~ Hy~la~: lo ,5'c'm.a'~ztics: insighls .h'o',~ Machismo 75"a'~,slalio:'L I%/nces Pint(,r, LOlldon, 1!)88. ['l'eich, 1992] Iqlkc Teich. Korea|: gra.l|tluar doc IIlllOlll;~lA.ioll. 'l'echnica] r